Paul Rudd has been playing the same prank on Conan O’Brien for 22 years. Twenty-two years. Let that sink in. While most celebrity feuds last months, most running jokes fade within seasons, Rudd has maintained this single bit of comedy for two decades, and Conan is now explicitly asking him to continue it on his deathbed.
How the Prank Started
February 2004. Late Night with Conan O’Brien. Paul Rudd appears to promote something (genuine movie promotion, completely legitimate). He tells Conan “I have an exclusive clip to show you.” Conan gets excited. Reasonable excitement. An exclusive clip? On late-night television? That’s compelling television.
Then the clip plays. It’s not what Conan expected. Instead of movie footage, viewers see a scene from Mac and Me—the 1988 sci-fi comedy featuring a young alien named Mac. Specifically, the scene where a kid falls off a cliff in a wheelchair.
That’s the entire prank. Setup: normal. Punchline: completely ridiculous. The genius is in Rudd’s commitment. He introduces this clip like it’s the most natural thing in the world. No winking at the camera. No breaking character. Just matter-of-fact introduction to absolute nonsense.
22 Years of Repetition
Rudd has returned to Conan’s shows—Late Night, The Tonight Show, Conan, and now his podcast Conan O’Brien Needs A Friend—approximately 35 times since 2004. He’s done the Mac and Me prank roughly 25 of those visits. Every single time, Conan falls for it (or pretends to, which somehow matters less because the bit works regardless).
What’s extraordinary is how Rudd has kept it fresh. He brings different clips from Mac and Me. He varies his delivery. He’s performed it hundreds of times, yet maintains the enthusiasm suggesting “I absolutely cannot wait to show you this” energy.
In 2025, Rudd appeared on Conan’s podcast promoting Anaconda. Conan clearly anticipated the prank. Every instinct screamed “Mac and Me incoming.” Rudd performed anyway. Because that’s the prank: it works precisely because it’s so predictable that predicting it doesn’t prevent its success.
Why This Matters
Twenty-two years of consistency in comedy is extraordinary. Most jokes die after the first telling. Repetition typically kills comedy. But Rudd and O’Brien transformed that rule. They proved that running gags can actually improve through repetition if executed with genuine affection.
There’s something beautiful about watching two grown men, across 22 years and multiple shows and television eras, maintain a single joke as pure act of friendship. They’re not doing it for attention. Rudd’s already successful. Conan’s already successful. They’re doing it because it makes them laugh. That’s profoundly pure comedy motivation.
The Deathbed Request
Here’s where it gets genuinely touching. On the podcast, Conan told Rudd: “When I’m on my deathbed, I want you to come in and show me Mac and Me. I want you to do one more clip. It’s going to bring me a lot of joy.”
That’s not a throwaway joke. That’s Conan explicitly telling Rudd that this running gag—this ridiculous, repeated, seemingly pointless prank—matters so much that he wants it to be his final memory. Conan, a legendary comedy writer, considers being pranked with Mac and Me significant enough to request on his literal deathbed.
Rudd’s response was appropriately touched but maintained the bit: “I’ll absolutely do it. I’ve got my best Mac and Me clips ready.”
The Comedy Lesson
The Mac and Me prank teaches something important about comedy: longevity beats novelty. The best jokes don’t punch hardest on first telling. They earn their power through repetition and commitment. Every prank succeeds not because it’s surprising (it’s not—everyone knows it’s coming), but because Rudd’s dedication makes it funny anyway.
That’s professional comedy writing. Not chasing new material constantly. Perfecting material through relentless repetition until the repetition itself becomes the joke.
Where We Are Now
As of December 2025, the prank remains undefeated. Rudd hasn’t performed it every single Conan appearance, but roughly 70% of visits result in Mac and Me footage. Conan has stopped pretending to be fooled. They’ve moved beyond the traditional setup-and-surprise structure into something more meta: the acknowledgment that they’re both in on it, performing it anyway because the performance matters more than the surprise.
That’s 22 years of comedians respecting their audience enough to do the same bit repeatedly, knowing the audience would rather see perfected repetition than forced novelty.
When Conan eventually does appear on his deathbed and Rudd shows up with Mac and Me, it’ll be the most meaningful punchline in decades of television comedy.
Also Read: 8 Epic Fantasy Shows Like Wheel of Time