Regretting You (2025) opened with minimal fanfare in October, accumulating just $8.2 million domestically despite featuring acclaimed actors Jude Law and Thomasin McKenzie. The film’s quiet devastation apparently didn’t translate into broad audience appeal.
Understated Tragedy
Directed by David Lowery (The Green Knight, A Ghost Story), Regretting You explores a suburban family confronting mortality through non-linear storytelling. Law plays a man discovered to have terminal cancer, forcing his wife (McKenzie) to recalibrate their relationship and life expectations.
The film contains minimal dialogue – many scenes feature characters sitting in silence processing emotional turmoil. Lowery’s approach prioritizes visual storytelling and actor performance over exposition. This stylistic choice alienates audiences seeking traditional narrative structure.
Critical Apathy
Despite strong performances from Law and McKenzie, critics divided sharply on Regretting You. Some praised its artistic ambition and emotional authenticity – Sight & Sound called it “the most honest depiction of cancer’s impact on relationships ever filmed.”
Others found the pacing interminable. The Hollywood Reporter noted “two hours watching characters suffer without hope exhausts viewers emotionally while offering minimal catharsis.” This criticism apparently resonated with general audiences who abandoned the film after initial screenings.
Financial Reality
Regretting You cost approximately $12 million to produce, making it unprofitable after factoring theatrical distribution costs. The limited 847-theater opening weekend generated just $2.1 million, suggesting audience resistance to this material.
The film now relies on streaming performance and international box office for financial recovery. Paramount+ acquired exclusive streaming rights for $4 million, reducing overall losses but disappointing studio projections.
Performance Context
Jude Law appears deliberately muted – his character’s emotional devastation manifests through physical withdrawal rather than dramatic outbursts. McKenzie responds to this energy with subtle vulnerability that requires careful viewer attention to appreciate.
Both actors deliver some of their career’s finest work, yet audiences apparently preferred escapist entertainment over profound character examination.
Legacy Status
Regretting You will likely become a cult favorite among patient viewers willing to engage with its intentional austerity. Film festivals and critics’ circles already championing the film as misunderstood masterpiece.
Lowery’s artistic vision clearly prioritized emotional truth over commercial viability. The film proves audiences have limited appetite for meditative cancer dramas lacking hope or resolution.
Also Read: Emily Blunt Teases The Devil Wears Prada 2 Development and The Smashing Machine Filming Stories