Ryan Gosling fired from Lovely Bones is the kind of Hollywood story that sounds fake until you remember this industry runs on ego and melted dairy products. Back in 2007, Gosling was cast as Jack Salmon—the grieving father in Peter Jackson’s adaptation of Alice Sebold’s novel. He was 27 years old and looked it. His solution? Gain sixty pounds by drinking melted Häagen-Dazs ice cream when thirsty. Method acting meets diabetes.
Peter Jackson took one look at this puffy stranger and said absolutely not. Ryan Gosling fired from Lovely Bones became official just days before filming began, with Mark Wahlberg stepping in to play the dad role that Gosling had literally eaten his way toward. The kicker? They barely spoke during pre-production. “We didn’t talk very much during the preproduction process, which was the problem,” Gosling admitted years later. “I just showed up on set, and I had gotten it wrong. Then I was fat and unemployed.”
The ice cream diet deserves its own documentary. Ryan Gosling fired from Lovely Bones over body transformation is wild enough, but the fact that he chose Häagen-Dazs specifically—melting it and drinking it like a protein shake—suggests a man who had never met a nutritionist and possibly never met common sense. He believed the character should weigh 210 pounds. Jackson believed the character should be played by someone who didn’t require a crane to get out of bed.
What’s fascinating is how Jackson recently addressed this at Cannes, taking the blame for the casting mismatch. “Anytime we recast an actor, it’s actually our fault because we didn’t get the casting right,” he said, calling Gosling a “fantastic actor.” Which is generous, considering Gosling showed up looking like he’d been inflated with a bicycle pump. Saoirse Ronan, who played his daughter, called the firing “valid” but “sad” since they’d bonded during prep.
Ryan Gosling fired from Lovely Bones ultimately worked out for everyone. Wahlberg gave a solid performance. Gosling moved on to better things and presumably better diets. And we got a perfect metaphor for Hollywood: one man’s artistic vision is another man’s melted ice cream nightmare. Sometimes you don’t get the role because you’re not right. Sometimes you don’t get it because you drank your weight in frozen dessert.
Watch the movie that wasn’t—stream The Lovely Bones and imagine the alternate universe where Ryan Gosling fired from Lovely Bones never happened.
Also Read: Masters Universe Posters Slap