Thanos snapped half the universe out of existence, collected all six Infinity Stones, and won so completely that the Avengers had to resort to time travel just to undo his work. And yet somehow, in the grand hierarchy of MCU villains, he’s still treated like the opening act. A new theory asks the obvious question that nobody seems willing to answer out loud. If Thanos won in billions of realities, why is he not considered the strongest being in the multiverse?
The Ancient One basically confirmed this during her conversation with Bruce Banner in Endgame. She explained that removing the Infinity Stones from their timeline creates branching realities where Thanos succeeds. Doctor Strange saw fourteen million possible futures and only found one where the Avengers won. Do the math. In almost every timeline that exists, Thanos comes out on top. That’s not a villain with a good plan. That’s a villain who is statistically inevitable, and that should count for something in the power rankings.
So why does Kang get treated like the bigger threat? The theory suggests something genuinely unsettling. What if Kang, or more specifically He Who Remains, wanted Thanos to win in those timelines? Think about it. He Who Remains spent eternity pruning timelines to maintain order. He had complete control over the Sacred Timeline. If Thanos was winning in billions of realities, it’s because someone with the power to stop him chose not to. He Who Remains allowed the Snap to happen because it served his larger purpose in ways we are only now beginning to understand.
Thanos was never the real enemy. He was a tool. A very destructive, very purple tool that wiped out half of all life so that the survivors would be desperate enough to do anything to fix it. That desperation led to the Time Heist, which led to branch timelines, which led to the multiverse collapsing, which led to exactly where we are now with Doctor Doom and the fractured Avengers. Thanos didn’t fail because he was weak. He failed because his victory was only supposed to last long enough to break the timeline beyond repair.
In the comics, Kang has beaten Thanos by aging him to death with time manipulation. He treats the Infinity Stones like trinkets and has infinite variants to replace any version that gets destroyed. Thanos is a brute force problem. Kang is a systemic one. And He Who Remains? He’s the guy who built the system. The theory argues that Thanos was allowed to win because his win was necessary. It created the conditions for everything that followed, including the events that will unfold in Doomsday.
So the next time someone tells you Thanos is the best MCU villain, you can correct them. He was the most successful pawn in a game he never knew he was playing. Thanos believed he was saving the universe through balance and sacrifice. In reality, he was just clearing the board for someone who had already seen the entire match play out from beginning to end. That’s not strength. That’s being used by someone stronger, and honestly? That’s way more tragic than anything the Russo Brothers gave us in Endgame. Thanos thought he was the main character. Turns out he was just the inciting incident.
Also Read: Endgame Encore Adds 4 Minutes Of Footage