The Conjuring Last Rites: The Smurl Family Case That Stumped Even the Warrens

Photo of author

By Mister Fantastic

The Conjuring Last Rites claims to be the final Warren film, and honestly, it’s about time. Based on the real Smurl family haunting in West Pittston, Pennsylvania, this September 6 release brings Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga back for their supposedly final paranormal investigation. Directed by Michael Chaves for New Line Cinema and Warner Bros., the film explores one case the Warrens famously never fully solved.

Janet and Jack Smurl on the back porch of their home on August 23, 1986 in West Pittston, PA.
Credit : AP Photo/Wilkes-Barre Times Leader/Carolyn Bauman
Janet and Jack Smurl on the back porch of their home on August 23, 1986 in West Pittston, PA.Credit : AP Photo/Wilkes-Barre Times Leader/Carolyn Bauman

Conjuring Last Rites True Story Gets Complicated

The real Smurl family moved into 330 Chase Street in August 1973, initially experiencing minor phenomena—cold spots, strange odors, mysterious scratches appearing on family members. By 1985, the activity escalated dramatically, with family patriarch Jack Smurl claiming sexual assault by a succubus entity. “We’re dealing with an intelligence here. It’s powerful, intangible, and very dangerous,” Ed Warren warned after investigating.

The Conjuring Last Rites true story gets murky when examining the evidence. Jack Smurl had undergone brain surgery for water removal in 1983, leading skeptics to attribute alleged hauntings to hallucinations from untreated medical conditions. Paul Kurtz, chairman for the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal, called the claims “a hoax, a charade, a ghost story.”

The Warrens’ Unsolved Case Creates Conjuring Last Rites Drama

Ed and Lorraine Warren began investigating in January 1986, documenting temperature drops, moving objects, and alleged communication with four distinct entities—three human spirits and one demonic force. “It was a frivolous lawsuit, to be honest. Very frivolous,” said Tony Spera, the Warrens’ son-in-law, regarding family members who later sued over exploitation claims.

Janet and Jack Smurl on the back porch of their home on August 23, 1986 in West Pittston, PA.
Credit : AP Photo/Wilkes-Barre Times Leader/Carolyn Bauman
Janet and Jack Smurl on the back porch of their home on August 23, 1986 in West Pittston, PA.Credit : AP Photo/Wilkes-Barre Times Leader/Carolyn Bauman

The Conjuring Last Rites screenplay, written by David Leslie Johnson-McGoldrick, dramatizes the case while addressing the Warrens’ retirement arc. In the film, their daughter Judy Warren (Mckenna Grace) develops stronger psychic abilities, eventually joining her parents for this final investigation. The movie explores how intense prayer and faith ultimately drove away the malevolent presence.

Janet and Jack Smurl on the back porch of their home on August 23, 1986 in West Pittston, PA.Credit : AP Photo/Wilkes-Barre Times Leader/Carolyn Bauman

Critics argue the Warrens profited from family tragedies, with some relatives claiming exploitation. However, Conjuring Last Rites positions their work as genuine spiritual warfare against supernatural evil. Whether audiences believe the Smurl haunting actually occurred, the film serves as an appropriately ambiguous conclusion to the franchise that made the Warrens household names in paranormal investigation.

Richard Busch of Pittsburgh, a consultant to the Committee for Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal, argues with Lorraine and Edward Warren of the New England Society for Psychic Research outside purportedly haunted home. 

Courtesy of Bettmann Archive
Richard Busch of Pittsburgh, a consultant to the Committee for Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal, argues with Lorraine and Edward Warren of the New England Society for Psychic Research outside purportedly haunted home. Courtesy of Bettmann Archive

James Wan executive produces while Michael Chaves directs, maintaining visual continuity with previous franchise entries. The film’s September 6 release positions it perfectly for horror fans seeking supernatural scares before October’s Halloween season arrives.

Also Read: Knives Out 3: Daniel Craig’s Final Case Gets December Date